The Problem with Direct Air Capture
It Takes a LOT of Air to Capture Carbon
One of the biggest challenges for carbon capture has always been not just the energy required to separate CO2 from air, but just how little CO2 there is in a volume of air. One cubic meter of air is only about 1225 kg, and even with CO2 concentrations rising towards 500ppm, that’s still less than 10kg of CO2 per cubic meter of air. That means capturing even one ton of CO2 per hour, a bit under 9k tons per year, requires processing over 100 m^3 of air per hour. The energy cost of the air handling alone can make up about half the energy used for standalone direct air capture. Alternative methods like enhanced rock weathering run into a similar challenge of the sheer surface area required to capture carbon. That just requires an enormous amount of infrastructure.
A Cost-Benefit Analysis of Using Direct Air Capture to Remove Atmospheric Carbon
Cost Problems
Durable and verifiable carbon credits, many using cheaper technology than direct air capture, currently sell for $200/ton. That leaves it up to the whims of government R&D programs and companies with ESG commitments that have more money than they know what ot do with. The cost of a ton of carbon emissions to the global economy is about $40, and even with optimistic electricity prices of $0.10, the pure energy cost of standalone direct air capture might already exceed that. Making carbon capture worth spending on at scale requires getting the cost below $40/ton, but priorities are fickle, and there’s a prisoner’s dilemma aspect, so reliably reaching the scales we need requires making it almost free, or even making it profitable.
Looking for Alternatives
Making carbon capture and sequestration work at the scales we need to combat climate change is going to require clever methods to bring the cost down dramatically. That means making the carbon capture itself economically useful, or finding ways to get it as a nearly free byproduct of something useful. If you can find clever ways to capture carbon for pennies on the dollar, and energy prices keep coming down, synthetic fossil fuel alternatives and productive carbon sequestration start to look viable.
Making Carbon Capture Affordable
Liquid Air Energy Storage
Liquid air energy storage, as currently sold by Highview Power, seems to be one of the few long-duration energy storage options that competes well with lithium-ion batteries. Its compact size and very low cost per kWh, as long as you don’t need a ton of kWs, and being geography-agnostic, make it really attractive for long-duration energy storage. It also requires liquefying a huge volume of air on every charge-discharge cycle. Because of the relative freezing and boiling points of nitrogen, oxygen, and CO2, getting the air cold enough to liquefy the oxygen and nitrogen freezes the CO2. That opens the opportunity to extremely cheaply capture pure CO2 by separating it during the air liquefaction process.
Building Ventilation Carbon Capture
Another potential avenue for cheap direct air capture is to integrate the direct air capture with a building ventilation system, as currently sold by Soltair Power. The building ventilation system already moves a huge amount of air, so that’s a significant part of the cost that’s already paid. CO2 capture also has the potential to work synergistically with the ventilation system to achieve an extremely low net cost. High indoor CO2 concentrations are uncomfortable and can make people irritable and less productive. Maintaining low indoor CO2 can require you to condition a lot of outside air, and increase ventilation flow, significantly increasing costs and potentially making the space drafty. Implementing direct air capture in the ventilation system allows it to maintain low indoor CO2 with much less outside air and less total flow. That recoups a significant portion of the cost of the direct air capture system, and in an office space with a very efficient electrochemical capture system, it could even be net energy positive.
https://www.soletairpower.fi/technology/
Replacing Ag-lime with Olivine
While it doesn’t produce pure CO2 for industrial uses, replacing Ag-lime with olivine, as pioneered by Eion Carbon, is one of, if not the most, cost-effective ways to do long-term carbon sequestration. Conventionally, farmers apply ag-lime as a pH balancer to control soil acidity. Crushed olivine is one of the key minerals for enhanced rock weathering, and like crushed limestone, it can act as a pH buffer to control soil acidity. That means that crushed olivine can be substituted almost 1:1 for ag-lime, even using the same equipment, and sequester significant CO2 while balancing soil pH. Eion Carbon currently relies on carbon credits, which, at $200/ton, more than cover the cost difference and monitoring to make the price to farmers slightly cheaper than ag-lime. With a supply chain on the same scale as ag-lime, I suspect that crushed olivine would reach price parity even without subsidies because it’s just another highly abundant crushed rock.
Speculative Opportunities
As the US and China are starting to actually develop commercial supercritical CO2 turbines, we can start looking at advanced supercritical CO2 power cycles like the Alam cycle. It’s extremely efficient and makes capturing the CO2 trivial, and could be combined with excess biogas for a cost-effective bio-energy with carbon capture system.
Desalination plants, which we will only need more of over time, have to pre-treat water, often including acid. Acidifying seawater also causes it to release CO2. Efficient CO2 capture requires much higher acidity, usually via electrolysis, but it could reduce the need for other pre-treatment, partially offsetting the cost.
What to do with Pure CO2
Intensive Enclosed Agriculture
Everything I can think of for cheap carbon capture, except crushed olivine, produces a stream of concentrated pure CO2. The question then becomes, what can you do with it that displaces fossil fuels or productively sequesters the CO2? One of the simplest uses is in high-intensity indoor agriculture. Both greenhouses and vertical farms use supplemental CO2 to support the extreme density of indoor plant growth. For cost reasons, the CO2 typically comes from burning something, which extremely cheap captured CO2 could displace, making the process cheaper and cleaner. Concentrated CO2 is also used as a feedstock for electro-agriculture, and a cheap source could go a long way to making it happen at scale.
Industrial Processes and Petroleum Substitutes
The next level of use for captured CO2 is in industrial processes that use CO2 already or can convert it into substitutes for petroleum products. The two main problems historically with synthetic petroleum products have been that fossil fuels were the cheapest energy source and that carbon capture is extremely energy-intensive. The energy cost of converting the CO2 to synthetic petroleum products is actually only ~2x the energy content of the product, and that becomes viable as renewables start to drive the cost of electricity below even natural gas. The other side to making that work is that the captured CO2 you’re using has to be pennies on the dollar, which I think we could do with the right approaches. That starts to make synfuels and plastics derived from atmospheric CO2 a viable alternative to conventional petroleum products.
Alternative Cement and Concrete Formulations
The most durable form of carbon sequestration is to trap it in carbonate minerals through rock weathering. The standard Portland cement we use now is based on reacting calcium oxide with water to form calcium hydroxide, and it does absorb some CO2 over time to form calcium carbonate. There is an ever-expanding breadth of research into ways to supercharge the carbonation reaction and incorporate other synthetic carbonate minerals to sequester CO2 in concrete. One of the major challenges is that many proposed materials require high concentration or pure CO2 to accelerate the carbonation process. Cheap high-concentration CO2 could make some of them cost-competitive without carbon credits. The scale of global cement and concrete production is so large that even a small change could sequester enormous quantities of CO2.

Leave a Reply